Today I'm angry. I'm angry with the Swiss school system. Because it is a good system but sometimes... Oh sometimes I just want to strangle this school system for being so.... grrrrr... plain out fastidious! Like
last week when my youngest daughter came home from school with a math test being
just one point away from a higher grade. The error was this:
"Steven has bought 2 bouquets of roses for his mom and they cost 6 CHF each. Tanya has bought 12 daisies and 10 tulips for her Mom. How many more flowers did Tanya buy than Steven?"
Do you know the answer? Well I certainly don't... So how would Emmy Bo know the answer? She is only 8 and of course she makes her best to guess an answer, and she fails.
"Steven has bought 2 bouquets of roses for his mom and they cost 6 CHF each. Tanya has bought 12 daisies and 10 tulips for her Mom. How many more flowers did Tanya buy than Steven?"
Do you know the answer? Well I certainly don't... So how would Emmy Bo know the answer? She is only 8 and of course she makes her best to guess an answer, and she fails.
I wrote the teacher asking: "What is the correct answer as the question
obviously is lacking enough information to receive a correct answer, or
did I miss something here? Maybe in Switzerland a bouquet of flowers
ALWAYS contains 12 flowers as a general rule. Something that everyone
should know... Or... Please, just fill me in. Because I don't feel that this is a correct question to have in a test. I'm sure Emmy Bo is not the only one who failed answering this question."
The teacher ignored my question for 4 days and after a reminder from me she finally responded:
"Well, that is a question without an answer and the correct answer should be 'I don't know.'"
Oh, how silly of me. Of course. Why didn't I get that? Of course tests should include questions where the answer is expected to be "I don't know.". I mean, we only study so hard to get it all right and to respond correctly to all questions in a test but of course we all should know that every now and then the school system sneaks in a "tricky one" which doesn't have an answer at all. Especially 8 year old kids should know this.
I'm sorry if I come out as being sarcastic but excuse me. Really??? Seriously???
Well, that trick question cost my daughter a point from a 5,5 instead of the 5 she got on her test. Luckily Emmy Bo is a strong girl and she won't be knocked down by this error, but someone else with maybe just a teeny weeny bit less self esteem could actually be really challenged by that kind of error. For another kid this might stir up some real anxiety for what questions will need an answer and what question will not in the future. There will always be a "trick question" hidden there somewhere... Scary...
I don't like it and I personally think it is bloody stupid to include trick questions in an 8-year old's math test. But that is my opinion and I'm an foreigner so maybe I should just keep my mouth shut.
Today I wish I spoke French fluently and comfortably, including curse words to let some steaming anger out, because if I did I would not have hesitated to go knock on that classroom door and question the teacher if this is truly within the regulations of a school plan. And I just wonder what she would answer. Maybe she would say "I don't know..."
Note: Thank you all for your comments and support on this topic. I have spoken to the teacher and it is a part of the curriculum so... Well, I guess I just have to suck it up and move on. I still find it strange though to say the least.
The teacher ignored my question for 4 days and after a reminder from me she finally responded:
"Well, that is a question without an answer and the correct answer should be 'I don't know.'"
Oh, how silly of me. Of course. Why didn't I get that? Of course tests should include questions where the answer is expected to be "I don't know.". I mean, we only study so hard to get it all right and to respond correctly to all questions in a test but of course we all should know that every now and then the school system sneaks in a "tricky one" which doesn't have an answer at all. Especially 8 year old kids should know this.
I'm sorry if I come out as being sarcastic but excuse me. Really??? Seriously???
Well, that trick question cost my daughter a point from a 5,5 instead of the 5 she got on her test. Luckily Emmy Bo is a strong girl and she won't be knocked down by this error, but someone else with maybe just a teeny weeny bit less self esteem could actually be really challenged by that kind of error. For another kid this might stir up some real anxiety for what questions will need an answer and what question will not in the future. There will always be a "trick question" hidden there somewhere... Scary...
I don't like it and I personally think it is bloody stupid to include trick questions in an 8-year old's math test. But that is my opinion and I'm an foreigner so maybe I should just keep my mouth shut.
Today I wish I spoke French fluently and comfortably, including curse words to let some steaming anger out, because if I did I would not have hesitated to go knock on that classroom door and question the teacher if this is truly within the regulations of a school plan. And I just wonder what she would answer. Maybe she would say "I don't know..."
Note: Thank you all for your comments and support on this topic. I have spoken to the teacher and it is a part of the curriculum so... Well, I guess I just have to suck it up and move on. I still find it strange though to say the least.
Kärlek
Annette
Annette




























